Histories of Our December Heritages
By Jim Myers

December is an important month for two of the world's great religions -- Rabbinic Judaism and Christianity.  It is also a very important month for many Americans -- especially businessmen.   Christmas falls on the 25th and all or part of Hanukkah is usually found in December.  As I researched my spiritual past it didn't take long to discover that what I had been taught about my December holiday and its actual history was not always the same.  In this article I will review the histories of Hanukkah and Christmas and then you can compare them with what you were taught and think about how to incorporate the new information in your spiritual journey.  I am blessed & empowered by both.

Hanukkah: 
Feast of Lights / Feast of Dedication

Hanukkah is the Jewish Feast of Lights or Feast of Dedication. The Hebrew word hanukkah (also written Hannuka or Chanukah) means dedication. The Hanukkah holiday begins on the eve of the 25th day of the Hebrew month of Kislev (approximately December) and lasts eight days.

The two books of Maccabees in the Apocrypha tell the story of Hanukkah.  The story began in Modin, a village not far from Jerusalem, after the Temple was seized and dedicated to the worship of Zeus. When the first Jew of Modin stepped up to the pagan altar to sacrifice according to the King's will, Mattathias, a priest whose family resided there, sprang out from the circle of bystanders, struck the man down so that his body was stretched out upon the altar, slew the agent of the government, and then pulled down the altar. 

A search was instituted in Judea for those who had disregarded the King's command and hidden themselves away in the wilderness. They were counting on the Jews resting on the Sabbath and thereby being vulnerable to capture.  Mattathias realized the situation: "If we all do as our brethren have done, and do not fight against the Gentiles for our lives and our ordinances, they will soon destroy us from off the earth."  Mattathias and his people therefore resolved, not indeed to attack, but at least to defend themselves on the Sabbath day. 

Even more significant is the fact that Mattathias ventured to interpret the law upon his own authority.  In his day this privilege was vested in the High Priest and his council, who governed Jerusalem and Judea.  When Mattathias, a man previously unknown, one priest among ten thousand, resolved to interpret the traditional law, to impose his interpretation upon the people, and thus to infringe upon the prerogatives of the High Priest, he raised himself, perhaps without intending to do so, to the position of an opposition government.  This was a major turning point in Jewish history.  They made a stealthy and roundabout entrance into the villages and summoned together those eager to fight; with the force thus formed they moved from place to place, destroying the idolatrous altars where they found them, compelling the observance of the Torah by force (for example, they circumcised newborn infants, as many as they found), and smiting apostate violators of the law.  The wrath of the Maccabees was poured over the Jews and not the Gentiles. 

For two years Judah Maccabee waged guerrilla war like his father, making surprise descents upon the apostates without venturing to attack walled cities or Jerusalem.  At first the central government paid no attention whatsoever to the Maccabean uprising.  The handful of Maccabees could only be regarded as another robber band on the highways.  But Judah was organizing his troops by appointing "captains of thousands, and captains of hundreds, and captains of fifties, and captains of tens."  It would appear that his force amounted to something more than three thousand men. 

The leaders in Jerusalem made no attempt at mustering its strength to put an end to the activities of the Maccabees.  Their failure is easy to understand if we reflect that they belonged to the upper strata of the people, being city dwellers and Jerusalemites, and did not particularly relish chasing after the Maccabees through gorges and over stony hills.  The mass of the peasantry, on the other hand, remained secretly devoted to the old faith.  Before a battle Judah's company fasted, clothed themselves in sackcloth, rent their garments, and prayed devoutly to the Lord of Hosts: "Behold, the Gentiles are gathered together against us to destroy us. . . . How shall we be able to stand before them unless Thou help us?" The Hasidim, "the pious ones," supported the Maccabees in their struggle.

In the fall Judah's success began to disturb the central government.  He appears to have controlled the road from Jaffa to Jerusalem, and thus to have cut off the royal party in Acra from direct communication with the sea and thus with the government.  It is significant that this time the Syrian troops, under the leadership of the governor-general Lysias, took the southerly route, by way of Idumea.  They encamped at Beth Zur, a fortress about 30 kilometers south of Jerusalem (whose remains have recently been excavated) that was the key to Judea from the south.  This new tactic proved correct. 

Judah was forced to quit his hiding place in the hills and hurry southward.  According to Jewish historical tradition, he then and there defeated Lysias.  But certain other documents which happen to be preserved indicate that the situation was much more complicated than the Jewish historians represent it to have been.  We see that the Maccabees sent deputies to Lysias to negotiate an understanding.  Lysias promised to intercede for them with the King, if they would maintain their "good will towards the state."  Menelaus, officiating High Priest and head of the reform party, intervened in the negotiations and appeared as mediator between the King and the Jews.  A Roman embassy, probably en route to Antioch, took the Jews' part and persuaded them to formulate their demands quickly so that they themselves might present them to the King.  Thus it appears that all parties were concerned to make peace between the government and the insurgents. 

Epiphanes resolved to call a halt to the persecutions.  In a proclamation to the Sanhedrin and the Jewish nation, he declared that he had been informed by Menelaus that the Jews who had fled from their homes -- that is, those loyal to the ancient faith, among whom were the Maccabees -- desired to return to their legal abodes.  Exemption from punishment was guaranteed all who returned by March 29, 164 BCE, and in addition the assurance was given that the Jews would be permitted "to use their own food and to observe their own laws as of yore."  The persecution was thus ended. 

The edict makes no mention of the Maccabees.  It is represented as an act of royal grace by Menelaus.  But such an interpretation could not conceal the true state of affairs.  The cessation of the persecutions signified the defeat of Menelaus, who had been their instigator, and the victory of the Maccabees -- something that must have seemed unbelievable to contemporaries.  Judah had won his victory with casual irregulars who were often lacking in such essential arms as sword and shield. 

Judah Maccabee and his soldiers went to the holy Temple, and were saddened that many things were missing or broken, including the golden menorah. They cleaned and repaired the Temple, and when they were finished, they held festivities in the Temple, and dedicated it to God.  According to the Talmud, written over five centuries after the event, when the Jews cleaned the Temple of Syrian idols, they found only one small cruse of oil with which to light their holy lamps. But miraculously, the cruse provided them with oil for eight days.

Other sources tell of a torchlight parade in the Temple, which may also have contributed to the tradition of lighting candles on Hanukkah. The Book of Maccabees, however, describes none of that. The book of Maccabees does connect Judah's celebration to King Solomon's dedication of the First Temple, when a miraculous fire descended from heaven. It makes a stronger case, however, for linking Judah's festivities to the holiday of Sukkot.  No mention is made of lights in relation to Hanukkah until about the year 100 CE, when Josephus speaks of a "Festival of Lights" commemorating the Maccabean victory. No mention again for several centuries until the name Hanukkah crops up full-blown in the Talmud and the story of the miracle appears, along with discussions about lighting the menorah.

According to Ami Isseroff: “Channuka was originally Chag Haurim - the festival of light. This leads to the suspicion that it, too, was a solstice holiday that existed before the victory of the Maccabees, which was welded unto it.”  The use of the name Hanukkah can only be documented from the first century CE.  Originally the festival was called "Tabernacles (Sukkot) of the month of Kislev," -- so, for example, in an official communication from the Palestinian to the Egyptian Jews, dated 124 BCE.

Many people, including scholars, overlook some very important aspects of the story of Hanukkah. 

(1) By instituting this festival Judah and his people declared themselves the true Israel, in contrast to the other Jews who were not members of their movement. 

(2) Judah's act of creating the festival of Hanukkah was one of far-reaching significance, because all previous festivals were authorized by the Torah (Hebrew Scriptures).  Never had a festival been instituted in Israel by human hand.  Even the restoration of the Temple after the Babylonian Exile had not been solemnized by the establishment of a day of commemoration.  Judah's act was therefore an innovation without precedent in Israel, but, on the other hand, it was in complete accord with the traditions of the Gentiles.  In Greek political theory the power to declare festivals, appoint priests, etc., was vested in the people (the demos), but such an idea was completely foreign to Judaism.  The Maccabees, the alleged opponents of foreign ways, adopted a Hellenistic practice for their own ends.  No one any longer celebrated the Greek festivals that served as Judah's example for his new Jewish festival.  But the eight-branched candelabrum, a symbol, again, that imitates a pagan usage, is lighted on Keslev 25 the world over. 

(3) The institution of daily prayer in the temple cult seems to have been an innovation of the Maccabean or Herodian period.  It certainly was not the work of "the prophets of old" or the First Temple.  None of the texts implies that prayer was part of the temple cult: Jews prayed at the temple, not in the temple. 

Hanukkah Today

Hanukkah this year begins at December 19 (at sundown) and last through December 26 (25 Kislev - 2 Tevet 5763).  Friends and family exchange gifts, put up Hanukkah decorations and light the Hanukkah Menorah, a really important part of the tradition and reflects the traditional name -- "the festival of light".   In commemoration of Hanukkah a special nine-branched candlestick is lit each of eight nights.  The highest candle, known as the Shamash or "servant", is used to light the other candles. Candles are placed in the menorah from right to left, but lit from left to right.

Blessings are said before the candles (three blessings on the first night, and two every night thereafter). The candles' light is not to be used for any other purpose other than contemplation of the miracle of Hanukkah—they should not be used to read by, or for any other secular function. The kindled menorah is displayed prominently in a front window or near a doorway and remains lit for at least half an hour after nightfall. The following blessing is only said on the first night before the traditional blessings that are recited every night.

Baruch ata Adonai, Elohenu melech ha-olam
she-hecheyanu, ve-kiyemanu, ve-higiyanu la-zeman ha-zeh.

 Blessed are you, Lord our G-d, King of the Universe, 
Who has kept us alive, and has preserved us, and enabled us to reach this season.

Traditional Blessing

 Baruch ata Adonai, Elohenu melech ha-olam
asher kideshanu be-mitzvotav, ve-tzivanu le-hadlik ner shel Hanukah.

 Blessed are you, Lord our G-d, King of the Universe,

Who sanctified us by his commandments, and has commanded us to kindle the lights of Hanukah.

Baruch ata Adonai, Elohenu melech ha-olam 
she-asa nisim la-avotenu ba-yamim ha-hem ba-zeman ha-zeh.

 Blessed are you, Lord our G-d, King of the Universe, 
Who wrought miracles for our fathers in days of old, at this season.

 Other Hanukkah Activities

Common traditions include singing Hanukkah songs, such as "Hanerot Hallalu" (Those Candles) and Ma'oz Tzur (Rock of Strength) and eating special "oily" delicacies such as latkes (potato pancakes) with applesauce and sour cream, or jelly doughnuts!  At Hanukkah it is traditional to eat good food, talk of the miracle of lights, and do good deeds for others. It is also customary to play a game of dreidel, which involves a spinning top with a different Hebrew letter printed on each side.

More recent traditions include the exchange of gifts and money, or "gelt," typically given as a reward to children for diligent religious studies. Some parents prefer to give their children chocolate coins wrapped in shiny gold foil. While there are many Hanukkah traditions, it is fun to invent your own meaningful family customs. Whether ancient or modern, serious or hilarious, your unique traditions can serve as the glue of family togetherness!

History of Christmas

 For the history of Christmas -- Click Here.

Join our Yahoo Group and discuss this article with others or just share your comments.
Click on "Home" below and then on "Yahoo Groups."

HOME

 

Free Web Counter
free counter

Thank you for visiting our site!
Sign up to receive BHC News & Updates by e-mail.

Tell a friend about our site -- click here.
Copyright 1999-2000-2001-2002-2003-2004-2005-2006-2007-2008 Biblical Heritage Center, Inc.
Jim Myers, Webmaster